Dude from high school upset about ACA and government mandates....
I'm very surprised that when one of my more left leaning friends makes a post I don't agree with and I comment but it gets deleted because I disagree. that kinda disturbs me. All I did was ask a question that has no answer. I wanted to see if I missed something. We all feel passionate about the issues but true ignorance is not considering the other side. It is a sad commentary to the state of things. Don't put political leaning stuff out there if all you're doing is propagandizing. So let me just ask the question now... Where in the constitution does it state the government has the power to make you buy insurance from a private company? I'd love to hear specifically. If you comment, just stick to this one question. Let's see what we get. Thanks... And no. Not tagging anyone either....
Tiltsta's response....
The Supreme Court has ruled that the mandate to purchase insurance is, in essence, a tax on those who fail to do so, which falls under the constitutionally designated power of Congress to create taxes. Like damn near everything, it isn't expressed in precise terms in the Constitution, so it is up to the Court to decide if it is within the legal boundaries of the Constitution. Whether or not one agrees with it, the Court has decided it is legal to levy this type of tax on mandates related to insurance. There are many pages of interpretations of this decision, and if it is or is not a trampling of the essence of the Constitution all over the web, most of which have clear political bias to them. The original decisions provide an interesting overview of the Court on taxation, fines, and the lack of applicability of mandates to the commerce clauses of the Constitution. Worth a read if you are interested in this kind of thing. I think the 'tax' decision was largely based on the fact that the government requests that you buy insurance and taxes those that do not. Once you have paid the tax, there is nothing else the government can do to you. It is an interesting take on things.