So yours had those different pickups rather than the lipsticks only?
Of course, NONE of this is happening now. I am going to explore my own gear to make sounds. Not dropping $500 on anything right now. The other $500-$700 guitar I would like to add to the arsenal is an AR50 like you have. I would like someday to have a true LP'ish type guitar. But, I do have a semihollow with humbuckers, and my HH strat. Still not the same as the shorter scale solid body paul type.
So yeah, the two guitars I would like to still add to what I have are that one, and a 12 of some kind.
Before today, I was just thinking of when I had money set aside, finding an old Yammy acoustic like I said. That I could either slap a sound hole pickup into or something. Or now consider the Dano route. The acoustic gives me that The Church thing. The Dano would be more toward that 60's jangle pop electric sound. But maybe the acoustic could be close enough.
But that is just window shopping for down the road. And it is possible I can get close enough, for my needs and the sounds I want to make, with stuff I have. At least for quite a while. Even if it is not a true 12 string sound.
Which informs which of the remaining two guitars should come first. It should be a 12. The LP lust can be satisfied well enough for my needs with my current guitars (I do have a short scale HH) and my pedal board.