BBC made a documentary series in 2019 called "I Can Go For That: The Smooth World Of Yacht Rock." It's on YT.
Part 1
Part 2
I grew up when it was called soft rock as I am from that era.
Calling it Yacht rock is just another generic term to classify it in a different generation.
Yeah, to me Yacht Rock is a specific subset with all of those groovy studio cats like McDonald, Lukather, Christopher Cross, etc. When you get "soft rock" it has Air Supply or Barry Manilow... neither of which I would put in that Yachting category.
My generation calls that mellow music back in our days. Never really considered Manilow or Air Supply rock, just pop like Taylor Swift.
In that period, they were. By today's standards, the classifications have changed. Just like Yacht Rock.Says the generation that gave "Jethro Tull" a "Heavy Metal" Grammy.
Donald Fagen Had Three Words for the ‘Yacht Rock’ Doc Director
https://www.rollingstone.com/music/...-yacht-rock-documentary-interview-1235166587/
The category was Hard Rock/Heavy Metal Vocal or Instrumental Performance. Most people expected Metallica to win because they were a popular Heavy Metal band at the time. Their music was getting airplay on radio and was charting well. Jethro Tull won for the song “Steel Monkey” which peaked at 84 on the charts and only stayed in top 100 for 4 weeks.Says the generation that gave "Jethro Tull" a "Heavy Metal" Grammy.
To add onto this, at the time Hard Rock/Heavy Metal was new so many of those bands fell under that moniker. Even Rush who today is defined as Prog Rock was under the HR/HM title.The category was Hard Rock/Heavy Metal Vocal or Instrumental Performance. Most people expected Metallica to win because they were a popular Heavy Metal band at the time. Their music was getting airplay on radio and was charting well. Jethro Tull won for the song “Steel Monkey” which peaked at 84 on the charts and only stayed in top 100 for 4 weeks.
Heavy Horses is a favorite Jethro Tull album of mine with a mix of acoustic and electric instruments. But, Ian Anderson is not the first singer to come to mind when considering great vocal performances and flute heavy rock is not particularly hard rock music in my book.
The controversy caused the Grammys to make 2 separate categories for Hard Rock and Metal the following year. In 1990, Metallica won a Grammy for “One.”
(Edit) I never listened to the Jethro Tull album “Crest Of A Knave.” I was unfamiliar with the song “Steel Monkey.” By contrast, I listened to a lot of Metallica’s album “And Justice For All” from roughly the same time period. I just listened to “Steel Monkey.” It’s fair to call it a Hard Rock song for that time (no flute) but neither the song, nor the vocal performance, were worthy of a Grammy IMO.