Question: Santo and Johnnny's Sleepwalk

BoomBoomBigelow

Genius of Love
An old friend of mine who resides in Chicago and is an artist, musician, and guitar builder, posted this on his Facebook page (I hesitate to post a link because I think Facebook is Shiva and Satan, or maybe LinkedIn is...I haven't decided):

Richard W Watts

about an hour ago ·



Questions I May Never Get Answered.

In yet another sailing excursion through YouTube the other day, I once again rolled up on a familiar favorite - "Sleepwalk", Santo and Johnny’s 1959 instrumental hit. This song has been kind of an enigma to me – almost a singularity. It has always been a favorite of mine. This is not because I’m mired in a case of deep nostalgia for my pre-teen years, because it has also hit a chord with guitar players of all ages over the years, and has become immortalized by, among others, Jeff Beck, Les Paul, Larry Carlton, Brian Setzer, The Shadows, The Ventures, Joe Satriani, and a long list of others who may not have recorded it, but know it intimately, like Chet Atkins and Leo Kottke. I think it is safe to say that if there were one song over a 50 year time period that all guitar players love, and it is essentially a very simple song, "Sleepwalk" would be a prime candidate. I’ve always wondered why that is?

The story is that two teenage Italian-American brothers from Brooklyn, Santo and Johnny Farina, in a fitful, dreamlike, late-night binge of inspiration, hammer out the essentials of Sleepwalk sometime in 1958/59, and it is released as a single in the summer of 1959 where it goes to the top of the charts. The orchestration is simple: Santo on steel guitar playing the “melody” line, and Johnny on electric guitar playing rhythm underneath his older brother’s lines. But what?.... a steel guitar as the lead instrument on an early rock-and-roll hit? Where, exactly, does THAT come from, and why is it in the hands of an Italian-American kid from Brooklyn?

In a time in which the only formats you ever heard steel guitar were in Western Swing and Hawaiian music, and strictly as a back-up instrument in country arrangements out of Nashville, how does an inner-city, streetwise New York kid of the 1950’s decide, "oh yeah! steel guitar’s IT for me, man!" (a triple-8 Fender – 3 necks, 8 strings each – no less) It seems as out of place in its milieu, as say, wearing a pink tutu on a date to the movies. And yet, it is a much loved classic that will likely live forever.

Especially in the earlier days of rock-and-roll, instrumental chart toppers were not unheard of -"Tequila" by the Champs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdMTl9zHQ9Y), "Miserlou" by Dick Dale and the Del Tones (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZIU0RMV_II8), "Walk Don’t Run" by the Ventures (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WW21rcHiVU0), and of course the later surf-hits "Wipeout" by the Surfaris (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p13yZAjhU0M), and "Pipeline" by the Chantays (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7c2ZKamzS4) - but mostly, their popularity did not survive intact into following decades except among niche groups. So why does Santo and Johnny’s singular hit maintain – even thrive?

At heart, Sleepwalk is a slow-dance, romantic ballad, with an early rock-and-roll chord structure, familiar for its day – but without vocals. If you were to listen to "Angel Baby" by Rosie and the Originals (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1st_9KudWB0), or "Donna" by Richie Valens (), both from around the same time, you would hear the structural similarities. Maybe more importantly, and less anachronistically for a couple of guys coming out of the streets of 1950’s Brooklyn would be the influence of Doo Wop (which was often practiced as vocal harmonizing without musical instrument accompaniment) and hits like "One Summer Night" by the Danleers (), and "In the Still of the Night" by the Five Satins ().

Now, go back and listen to a higher fidelity version of "Sleepwalk" (). After you get past the intro, listen how Santo digs into the melody line. It comes on as a scream, a wail, but falls quickly back to a moan, a lament. He slides with the precision of a master and holds the vibrato for prolonged effect before wailing again. He stutters. He breathes. In the Dick Clark TV version below, Santo looks like he could still be 18 years old, but he plays with the subtlety and depth of a practiced master of the instrument. Teenagers, of course, are avid learners and are often quite athletically adept on their instrument of choice, but subtlety and depth are usually much harder, and longer, to come by. Having a little more life behind you helps a great deal, but Santo nails it. There is no better version of this song, that I’m aware of, than Santo and Johnny’s original. Simplicity of structure, minimal orchestration, and absolute fearless passion in nailing those notes. Humbling, really. A vocal track over the top of this would add nothing (in fact there was a version by a Betsy Brye around the same time that carried vocals – it was forgettable.) The odd thing is that the most ardent and passionate defenders of this song have always been guitar players, not steel players. They probably consider it too easy, but guitar players have always seen the possibility in this song – and have tried a million ways to get those ringing, high harmonics, the slides, the melody line, and the chord structure all simultaneously onto a single instrument playing in real time while trying to hold the passion of the original together. I think that’s why it appeals. Nobody’s really done it yet (because we don’t have enough hands to quickly change from “slide” to “no slide”, or standard tuning to more “slide friendly” altered tuning and back, or enough fingers to simultaneously fret chords and play slide melody lines), but several have come close, and one day … who knows?
 
A+

He's dead on. I've always loved that song and I don't really know why. I really dig Setzer's take. I'd love to try and tackle that some day (or year, more like it).
 
There are a lot of shaky premises here. Steel guitar was prominently featured in most of Hank Williams' records, all of which were released well before 1959. Hank had his share of crossover hits, and boys in Brooklyn were just as taken with cowboy movies (with their steel-infused soundtracks) as they were in the rest of the country.

With regards to the instrument, I'd suspect, while he may be playing a triple-neck instrument in some footage, that Santo started on a non-pedal model. I don't hear a lick of pedal work in there. There was a lap steel boom a couple years back, when the manufacturers realized they could sell an instrument without having to fuck around with frets, truss rods, necks, and such, and could sell a plank with a foot of wiring for $100. The same thing happened in the 50s.

As for pedal steel players never playing the song, there's a couple of things going on. It's probably in C6 tuning, which very few pedal steel players use nowadays. And it's not a country song, which is pretty much all that gets played on the PSG nowadays (I'm sure the sacred steel guys aren't covering it, either).

Finally, it's absurd to posit that this song has stood the test of time, whereas other instrumentals haven't. I'm thinking Tequila and Wipeout have far more nostalgic cache (I'm sure a survey of movie soundtracks depicting the period would bear that out). I think "Rebel Rouser" is on the Forrest Gump soundtrack, and "Rumble" gets around, too.

Great song, but it's not a mystery.
 
It took me a while to type that--the thread was clean when I started. Hope my thoughts aren't seen as a refutation of anyone above me...
 
I downloaded the tab for this tune (arranged for guitar) the day that UnitedWeTab.com shut down. I lost it, but I can still find the sheet music for "Flight of the Bumblebee" I downloaded in the same crush.
 
There are a lot of shaky premises here. Steel guitar was prominently featured in most of Hank Williams' records, all of which were released well before 1959. Hank had his share of crossover hits, and boys in Brooklyn were just as taken with cowboy movies (with their steel-infused soundtracks) as they were in the rest of the country.

With regards to the instrument, I'd suspect, while he may be playing a triple-neck instrument in some footage, that Santo started on a non-pedal model. I don't hear a lick of pedal work in there. There was a lap steel boom a couple years back, when the manufacturers realized they could sell an instrument without having to fuck around with frets, truss rods, necks, and such, and could sell a plank with a foot of wiring for $100. The same thing happened in the 50s.

As for pedal steel players never playing the song, there's a couple of things going on. It's probably in C6 tuning, which very few pedal steel players use nowadays. And it's not a country song, which is pretty much all that gets played on the PSG nowadays (I'm sure the sacred steel guys aren't covering it, either).

Finally, it's absurd to posit that this song has stood the test of time, whereas other instrumentals haven't. I'm thinking Tequila and Wipeout have far more nostalgic cache (I'm sure a survey of movie soundtracks depicting the period would bear that out). I think "Rebel Rouser" is on the Forrest Gump soundtrack, and "Rumble" gets around, too.

Great song, but it's not a mystery.

I didn't really buy the "no other instrumental has stood the test of time" bit either. There are tons.

But I don't think the OP was saying that nobody else was playing steel. He was saying that it was mostly a background instrument, it was mostly used in Nashville for country songs, and it's a bit odd that a young boy from NY was using as a lead instrument on a Pop tune. I think his point was kind of making out to be similar to Jethro Tull's flute as a major component in a prog rock band, or a fiddle in a pop-punk band like Yellowcard. It's just not common.

But regardless of the arguable bits, it was still a fun read, and a great song.
 
But I don't think the OP was saying that nobody else was playing steel. He was saying that it was mostly a background instrument, it was mostly used in Nashville for country songs, and it's a bit odd that a young boy from NY was using as a lead instrument on a Pop tune. I think his point was kind of making out to be similar to Jethro Tull's flute as a major component in a prog rock band, or a fiddle in a pop-punk band like Yellowcard. It's just not common.

But regardless of the arguable bits, it was still a fun read, and a great song.
I'm saying steel was tied with fiddle as THE lead instrument in C & W music, which was featured prominently in cowboy movies, which were just about the most popular films at the time. Being surprised that a kid in Brooklyn was into steel, even though it's a country instrument, is like being surprised to see a kid in Brooklyn in a coonskin cap.
 
But I don't think the OP was saying that nobody else was playing steel. He was saying that it was mostly a background instrument, it was mostly used in Nashville for country songs, and it's a bit odd that a young boy from NY was using as a lead instrument on a Pop tune.

I'm saying steel was tied with fiddle as THE lead instrument in C & W music, which was featured prominently in cowboy movies, which were just about the most popular films at the time. Being surprised that a kid in Brooklyn was into steel, even though it's a country instrument, is like being surprised to see a kid in Brooklyn in a coonskin cap.

The other side of the whole steel guitar issue is that there was a huge Hawaiian-influenced steel guitar trend from the 20's through the 50's that's largely forgotten these days. Plenty of examples of bands all across America that adopted Hawaiian names and played American pop standards with the steel guitar front and center. The idea to use a steel guitar on a non-country song wasn't exactly new.

Which is not to take anything away from "Sleepwalk." It's a great instrumental.
 
To me it has such a sparse, melancholy feel and doesn't seem to be trying too hard like wipeout or walk don't run, that may be the allure. It hasn't really been overplayed and forced down peoples throats over the years. I think when people hear it, it's been a while and they think, 'oh yeah, this song is great, I remember it'. I love playing sleepwalk, and have worked on it now and then over the years. I don't even play it as a slide tune though, I just do some bending, even though I do play some slide now and again. I just like it's simplicity, and the haunting melody. just my .02
 
There are a lot of shaky premises here. Steel guitar was prominently featured in most of Hank Williams' records, all of which were released well before 1959. Hank had his share of crossover hits, and boys in Brooklyn were just as taken with cowboy movies (with their steel-infused soundtracks) as they were in the rest of the country.

With regards to the instrument, I'd suspect, while he may be playing a triple-neck instrument in some footage, that Santo started on a non-pedal model. I don't hear a lick of pedal work in there. There was a lap steel boom a couple years back, when the manufacturers realized they could sell an instrument without having to fuck around with frets, truss rods, necks, and such, and could sell a plank with a foot of wiring for $100. The same thing happened in the 50s.

As for pedal steel players never playing the song, there's a couple of things going on. It's probably in C6 tuning, which very few pedal steel players use nowadays. And it's not a country song, which is pretty much all that gets played on the PSG nowadays (I'm sure the sacred steel guys aren't covering it, either).

Finally, it's absurd to posit that this song has stood the test of time, whereas other instrumentals haven't. I'm thinking Tequila and Wipeout have far more nostalgic cache (I'm sure a survey of movie soundtracks depicting the period would bear that out). I think "Rebel Rouser" is on the Forrest Gump soundtrack, and "Rumble" gets around, too.

Great song, but it's not a mystery.

Ok, Mr. Debateophile. Let me refresh my glass of Raspberry Lemonade Crystal Light, take a quick power nap, relight my cigar and unlock the secret Premier Guitar schoolroom. C'mon in.
Firstly, point taken on the availability of Fender Steels. This was Leo's stock-in-trade, prior to the Broad/Telecaster. As well as the popularity of the PSG in popular music. As well as the popularity of C&W and Steel laden Texas swing, at the time. That's a given. They were practically selling them door to door. This, I suppose was the palette of that moment.

However, this was by no means a "country" song. Maybe Dick's inferring the use of contemporary American tools to express a timeless, placeless music highly infused with local sentiment.

So it may have been C6 tuning, common then, of course, not popular with country PSG players now? So what?
To quote you "And it's not a country song". Of course it's not. Why then would "country" artists cover it.

His point was how is it that premier guitar players such a Beck, Satriani, Les Paul, Carlton, Setzer, The Shadows, The Ventures, deem it worthy of covering?
Tequila, Wipeout, Rumble, of course all good time party garage three chord classics, in nearly every guitar player's primary repertoire but none present the emotional finesse challenge of Sleepwalk.

How's your mom? Say hi to her for me.
 
I still say, this is the best "modern" song ever written. I think I made a thread about it on HC at some point. It is, in every possible way, a perfect song.
 
Ok, Mr. Debateophile. Let me refresh my glass of Raspberry Lemonade Crystal Light, take a quick power nap, relight my cigar and unlock the secret Premier Guitar schoolroom. C'mon in.
Firstly, point taken on the availability of Fender Steels. This was Leo's stock-in-trade, prior to the Broad/Telecaster. As well as the popularity of the PSG in popular music. As well as the popularity of C&W and Steel laden Texas swing, at the time. That's a given. They were practically selling them door to door. This, I suppose was the palette of that moment.

However, this was by no means a "country" song. Maybe Dick's inferring the use of contemporary American tools to express a timeless, placeless music highly infused with local sentiment.

So it may have been C6 tuning, common then, of course, not popular with country PSG players now? So what?
To quote you "And it's not a country song". Of course it's not. Why then would "country" artists cover it.

His point was how is it that premier guitar players such a Beck, Satriani, Les Paul, Carlton, Setzer, The Shadows, The Ventures, deem it worthy of covering?
Tequila, Wipeout, Rumble, of course all good time party garage three chord classics, in nearly every guitar player's primary repertoire but none present the emotional finesse challenge of Sleepwalk.

How's your mom? Say hi to her for me.
That's a lot of hostility.

The OP wondered why no pedal steel players play this song. My guess that it was in C6, and the fact that it's not a country song, were answers to this question. This era isn't too far from the wave of "Polynesian" influence, where the annexation of Hawaii and other territories had people building tiki lounges, drinking Mai Tais, and so on. There were scores of instrumental steel records playing pop and jazz hits of the day. So, the "how did an Italian kid in Brooklyn wind up playing a hillbilly instrument?" question trades on stereotypes of both the person and the instrument that are unfounded.

The question of why so many guitarists cover it remains. If I were to take a stab at it, I'm thinking that 80% of the other instrumentals of the era either weren't on a stringed instrument at all, or had sections that were taken by other instruments. "Tequila" was all horns, "Wipeout" had the drums, I think "Miserlou" had a horn break, etc. So the guitarist keeps the spotlight throughout. It's a song that's rich and complex (all those creamy double stops, and the harmonics in that intro lick), unlike "Rumble" or "Walk Don't Run", and it's not technically demanding, like "Miserlou" or "Sabre Dance". It's the same reason vocalists like to cover "Unchained Melody" instead of "Wild Thing".
 
you're silly. it's a great song. the OP's hypothesis (well, R.Watts') is that it is so perfect that it can't be bettered. post your version......
 
Funny thread is funny.

In regards to Sleepwalk... I fucking hate that song.

Interesting reads though.

Sent from my Transformer TF101 using Tapatalk 4
 
That's a lot of hostility.

Sorry. It was mock hostility. I'm very good-natured. All my posts on this forum are meant in good fun. I forgot to add this after my opening statement :grin:. Forgive me.

The OP wondered why no pedal steel players play this song. My guess that it was in C6, and the fact that it's not a country song, were answers to this question. This era isn't too far from the wave of "Polynesian" influence, where the annexation of Hawaii and other territories had people building tiki lounges, drinking Mai Tais, and so on. There were scores of instrumental steel records playing pop and jazz hits of the day.
I thought we more or less agreed here.


So, the "how did an Italian kid in Brooklyn wind up playing a hillbilly instrument?" question trades on stereotypes of both the person and the instrument that are unfounded.

That's not how I put it. Let me clarify by modifying my statement: Maybe Dick's inferring his wonderment at the use of contemporary American tools ("hillbilly instrument"), and context ("Italian kid in Brooklyn"), to express a timeless, placeless music highly infused with local sentiment --I think here he was referring to the popular music Doo-wop scene in New York rather than "Italian kid in Brooklyn". Dick did not use those stereotypical terms. You did.

The question of why so many guitarists cover it remains. If I were to take a stab at it, I'm thinking that 80% of the other instrumentals of the era either weren't on a stringed instrument at all, or had sections that were taken by other instruments. "Tequila" was all horns, "Wipeout" had the drums, I think "Miserlou" had a horn break, etc. So the guitarist keeps the spotlight throughout. It's a song that's rich and complex (all those creamy double stops, and the harmonics in that intro lick), unlike "Rumble" or "Walk Don't Run", and it's not technically demanding, like "Miserlou" or "Sabre Dance". It's the same reason vocalists like to cover "Unchained Melody" instead of "Wild Thing".

Excellent point.
 
Back
Top