BlockInlay
Octavate.band
Self chosen pain? Bread stolen from the mouths of decadence? Over exposed and commercialized?
Three bands enter, one band leave.
Three bands enter, one band leave.
Mad Season vs Temple of the Dog vs The Traveling Wilburys
- Thread starter BlockInlay
- Start date
MonkeyZero
Mexican Mayonnaise Weiner Sandwich
First thought is TotD but I was listening to Artificial Red on the way to work this morning and Mad Season has a fighting chance here.
I don't hate Traveling Wilburys but they are misplaced in this battle.
I don't hate Traveling Wilburys but they are misplaced in this battle.
VoidTerraFirma
Live to wine
Mad Season.
Motorik
Kick Henry Jackassowski
Off the top of my head, I can't think of any 'supergroup' that is better than the original acts.
Even CSN&Y.
MonkeyZero
Mexican Mayonnaise Weiner Sandwich
Slipknot is better than Stone Sour. Does that count? lol
Peen Simmons
Let’s Get Obtuse!
Well, only one of those groups has a Nobel Prize winner dunking on Springsteen via an excellent parody track, so...
GusChiggins
Worried about coyotes
Hunger Strike?
Peen Simmons
Let’s Get Obtuse!
Woah, indeed. Orbison looked like he was in his late 60s around the time he died.
Motorik
Kick Henry Jackassowski
His age was really deceptive. He was 24 when he released 'Only the Lonely', yet already seemed like a man in his 40s.
BlockInlay
Octavate.band
Well, it's alright. he looked like he was in his 60's in the 60's
DdBob
Dogue in teh desert
We see what you did there! He may have been in his 60s but it was not the end of the line.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Lerxst
spaghetti and blankets
I'm not even talking better...imo the output of these three groups falls far shy of the mark.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_musical_supergroups
There's several contenders on that list even if supergroup is taken loosely
335clone
Living the dream
Very loose interpretation. Like "a band that has members that were in some other band at some point".
Gary Blanchard
beloved, local musician
I happen to be a Wilburys fan. I don't see them as a super group, I see the Wilbury's as a way for five guys to have fun with music without worrying about their legacies.
Knox in Box
Rustbelt refugee.
Temple for me, by about two lengths over a strong showing by Mad Season.
Dogsinplastic
avuncular to no one
I think the Temple of the Dog album is a masterpiece.
I enjoyed the Wilburys, but while fun the material is nowhere near the quality of their respective outside projects. Semantically, they are the only real "super" group of listed. Harrison, Petty, Dylan, Orbison...holy shit is all I'm saying. The RnR hame of fame doesn't really mean anything/carry any weight, but all of these guys are in there and all made significant impacts on rock/popular music. I'm not sure any supergroup comes close from that perspective. I remember Petty talking about it back when first came out, how he was living the dream. Imagine whoever your Dylan and Harrison are wanting to play with you...the honor and validation (also ego boost).
Temple is just Chris singing w/ PJ...yeah, Matt's there too, but that had more to do w/ drummer issues for MLB & PJ (obviously before Cameron got the gig). Mad Season never appealed to me...they just didn't catch my ear.
I enjoyed the Wilburys, but while fun the material is nowhere near the quality of their respective outside projects. Semantically, they are the only real "super" group of listed. Harrison, Petty, Dylan, Orbison...holy shit is all I'm saying. The RnR hame of fame doesn't really mean anything/carry any weight, but all of these guys are in there and all made significant impacts on rock/popular music. I'm not sure any supergroup comes close from that perspective. I remember Petty talking about it back when first came out, how he was living the dream. Imagine whoever your Dylan and Harrison are wanting to play with you...the honor and validation (also ego boost).
Temple is just Chris singing w/ PJ...yeah, Matt's there too, but that had more to do w/ drummer issues for MLB & PJ (obviously before Cameron got the gig). Mad Season never appealed to me...they just didn't catch my ear.