Psychotronic
Bored Silly
AND I can swap out different pedals to suit the gig, which I do quite often (and is why my board is a mess).
This thread makes me glad I play acoustic. Wow.
Here's mine at the moment:
I have 3 or 4 flavors of modulation (chorus, phase, flange, and tremolo if you count that), 2 DDL's (one with a tap tempo), and a comp. I can get "pretty close" to just about everything (within reason) with this. I like nailing tones too, but it's a case of diminishing returns -- as long as you're close enough, you know that the audience really won't even notice.
I don't plan on ever going back to programmable set-ups -- too fussy for live use, as you obviously know.