Love Bill, his playing, sound, writing, the whole package. That said I don't care for the Beach Boys and definitely not Surfer Girl as a tune. Despite being significantly better than the original, I'm not feeling this. My lack of like seems rooted in not caring for the melody and the harmonic development, not just the Beach Boys...or my bias regarding to the BBs is too much to overcome. Ima go with the former, but it's likely more the latter.
Is this an album of Beach Boys covers? (he asked before going off to find the answer on his own).