I'm sorry, but I have to ask: Mark, exactly how many OD/Dist pedals do you have?
A bunch, but I flip them too. I just sold my Prince of Tone since it wasn't getting used and my Mojo Hand FX Rook is also for sale.
I currently own:
3 Xotic RC Boosters - one in my large board, the Scott Henderson dual mode version that rides in my gig bag and another one for my smaller board.
Voodoo Lab Sparkledrive MOD on my large board - I try constantly to replace this pedal and it never goes away. It's my main coverband overdrive in the "MOD 1" position without the mid hump.
Wampler Pinnacle Deluxe on my large board - it gets used about 3 times a night for the 80's and 90's metal tunes. Another pedal I always think I can do better than but its still there.
I also have a Giggity that Voodoo Lab sent me for free that sits in my studio case but I can't get rid of it since I didn't pay for it - thats bad juju when you do that. I do need to experiment with it a bit more though.
Ibanez TS9 mini thats currently in my small board but will probably be replaced by the Tumnus go into reserve.
At some point in the near future I need another overdrive for my small board and a fuzz. Right now I'm not in any hurry unless I find something cool at Namm. I also am on the Analogman King of Tone wait list but I won't see that for another year I bet.